Friday, March 19, 2010

Under the Covers is playing from a friend's computer the other day when the strains of a familiar melody ooze from the speakers.

But, something is different.

The Jewel version of Lynyrd Skynyrd's "Sweet Home Alabama" is another example of an artist putting their own spin on a song that inspires them. Whether their cover version is any good is a whole other story and anyone who saw Celine Dion trying to belt out AC/DC's "You Shook Me All Night Long" will know what we're talking about.

Cover songs can help take a career to new level as was the case with The Beatles and their 1963 version of "Twist and Shout", originally recorded by the Isley Brothers three years earlier. The Fab Four recorded their version in a single take for their debut album – and the world changed. John Lennon's lead vocal sounds as raw and urgent as a live concert, a gritty departure from the techno-driven, computerised sounds of today.

So what makes a great cover song? Is it a seamless, letter-perfect rendition of the original? How far it can be twisted from the original while still maintaining the song’s essence? Or is about putting that unmistakable personal stamp on it?

Just for a little Friday fun, let's reflect on what might be considered as the TSB "Top 5 Cover Songs" of all time. "Crossroads" by late sixties power trio Cream merits consideration after it was first recorded by blues legend Robert Johnson in 1936. Aretha Franklin hit "Respect" out of the park in 1967, taking the Otis Redding original and turning it into a girl power anthem. Manfred Mann Earth Band lifted "Blinded by the Light" to new heights after the Bruce Springsteen original failed to chart. And let's not forget the way Billy Idol was able to energize "Mony Mony" with a rebel yell; a far cry from the bubblegum original performed by Tommy James and the Shondells in 1968.

Other numbers that warranted consideration were Metallica's version of bob Seger's "Turn the Page", the Elvis rendition of "Hound Dog" as well as Cheap Trick taking a page from Elvis with "Don't Be Cruel".

So after much thought, reflection and the odd semi-heated debate, here are the official, TSB Top 5 Cover Songs of all time:

#5. "American Woman" - LENNY KRAVITZ

Canadian rockers The Guess Who, featuring the songwriting team of Randy Bachman and Burton Cummings soared to the top of the charts in 1970, before Lenny Kravitz reworked it with some of his magic in 1998.

#4. "Hurt" - JOHNNY CASH

Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails wrote it, but "The Man in Black" made it his own with heartfelt sincerity and meaning.

#3. "You Really Got Me" - VAN HALEN

The Kinks helped accelerate the "British Invasion" of 1964, but Eddie Van Halen cranked it up with this blistering version in the late seventies and changed guitar rock guitar forever. Van Halen also took a number of other originals to the mean streets such as Roy Orbison's "Pretty Woman" and Linda Ronstadt's, "You're No Good".

#2. "Me and Bobby McGee" - JANIS JOPLIN

Kristofferson wrote it, but Joplin turned it into a classic and became a legend in the process.

And finally ... the most coveted position on this countdown, goes to the cover version of a song that inspired the entire genre known as Hop Hop with an assist from Aerosmith.

#1. "Walk This Way" - RUN-DMC

"The thing about hip-hop is that it's from the underground, ideas from the underbelly, from people who have mostly been locked out, who have not been recognized"


Jean-Marc said...

That's a great line-up. I was surprised when I learned that Johnny Cash covered a Nine Inch Nails song, and that it wasn't the other way around. We're used to hearing of hard rock bands taking mellow songs and giving it that extra kick. One that comes to mind is how Limp Bizkit took George Micheals' "Faith" and twisted it in their raw & angst filled style they became famous for on their debut album.

But we have a local artist that deserves an honorary mention on here. Chris Colepaugh is getting loads of airplay with his rendition of Neil Young's "After the Goldrush".

If you haven't heard it yet, check it out:

Mike Shanks PSP said...

Just to provide an obscure but amazing cover. Petra Haden and the Sell Outs belt out an accapella version of Journey's Don't Stop Believing.

Gair Maxwell said...

Great comments and contributions guys .. this subject is endlessly interesting when you look at the way music can be interpreted so differently by different artists... for my money Johnny Cash was one of the best and another worthy consideration was what he did with "Rusty Cage", originally recorded by Soundgarden

Here is the original:

And here is the "Man in Black" treatment:

It will be interesting to see what other TSB readers contribute today as we continue to "Turn the Page" on this subject.

Metallica style:

Anonymous said...

感謝分享 功德無量........................................